Private capital and insurance: two-way traffic
Private capital and insurance are becoming increasingly interconnected as both sectors consolidate and seek scale. Competition, higher technology and compliance costs, and a more challenging fundraising environment are encouraging private capital firms to grow assets under management and diversify their investment strategies. Against this backdrop, insurance presents a compelling opportunity.
Private capital can participate in insurance in several ways. Acquiring insurers or reinsurers provides access to significant pools of premium-derived assets that can generate investment returns, while investment in brokers, agents and service providers can support buy-and-build strategies that generate synergies and economies of scale. Insurance, particularly non-life, can also provide diversification from traditional debt and equity markets, alongside opportunities to earn investment-management and service fees.
There are, however, significant challenges. Insurance is a highly regulated, long-term business, which can conflict with traditional private equity investment horizons and expectations around shareholder control. (Re)insurers face substantial capital, governance and regulatory requirements, while the unpredictability of insurance cycles can make achieving an optimal exit difficult. These issues have contributed to regulatory scrutiny of private capital ownership, particularly around investment time horizons and the potential movement of insurers' portfolios towards less liquid or more volatile assets.
The relationship also works in the opposite direction, with insurers increasingly investing in private capital. Private assets can offer materially higher potential returns than public corporate bonds, as well as diversification benefits. However, under UK and EU solvency regulation, capital charges and the prudent person principle constrain insurers' ability to invest heavily in illiquid assets.
As insurers grow through consolidation, they are increasingly gaining the scale and sophistication needed to assess and invest in private capital opportunities. The result is likely to be continued convergence between the two sectors, with private capital becoming both a more significant owner of insurance businesses and investment destination for insurers.
Read the full article here.